Digg’s Kevin Rose announced on Digg the Blog yesterday that they finally managed to launch the long-expected new comment system on Digg.
Digg users have complained about the poor comment system for a really long time now. As a regular Digger, I must say that I’ve also never been a fan of the system - good looking, but definitely lacking some features (where threading seemed to be the most important). The new system brings some new features, but - unfortunately - the overall impression is even worse than it was before. As the whole community agreed: it sucks.

Why it sucks?
Though it does support multiple level comments now, it’s - in my opinion - poorly designed, the comments just don’t look as neat as they did before. The second thing I don’t like about it is the fact that, after opening a story, only the “first” comments are visible. To view any replies, you have to open the Comment Display Options (one click), then choose the Expand Full Tree option (second click…), or just click a link to open the replies to the comment which interests you (lots of clicks). I understand that the idea behind it was to make the pages load faster, and for those of you who don’t really care about comments, it’s not a big deal. But I usually like to at least skim through ALL comments under stories that interest me and having to make at least two additional clicks to do so is, for me, a huge step backwards in usability.
The one thing I like about the new system is replying in context; it means that when you reply to a comment, the text area appears right below it - you are not thrown to bottom anymore, so you can read the comment you are replying to while typing your own.
Well, hopefully I’ll get used to it :)
For more information and opinions, check out the David Burka’s (Digg’s creative director) blog.
Tags: digg